Why I Still Wouldn't Buy Palantir Stock -- Even After Its Recent Sell-Off

Why I Still Wouldn’t Buy Palantir Stock — Even After Its Recent Sell-Off

The palantir stock price has been a rollercoaster in 2025, captivating investors with its meteoric rise and now testing their nerves with a sharp pullback. Just a few weeks ago, shares of Palantir Technologies (NYSE: PLTR) touched an all-time high of $207.52 on November 3, fueled by hype around its AI-driven software platforms and blockbuster quarterly results. Fast-forward to today, November 24, and the palantir stock price sits around $160.68, down more than 22% from that peak and marking a five-day losing streak that wiped out billions in market value. Year-to-date, it’s still up an impressive 150%, making it one of the top performers in the AI frenzy. On paper, this dip might scream “buy the dip” – a classic opportunity for value hunters eyeing a beaten-down tech darling. But after digging into the numbers, the news, and the broader market dynamics, I’m sticking to my guns: I still wouldn’t touch Palantir stock with a ten-foot pole. Let me explain why, step by step, without the sugarcoating.

Palantir’s story is the stuff of Silicon Valley legend. Founded in 2003 by a trio of PayPal Mafia alumni, including Peter Thiel, the company built its reputation on secretive government contracts, crunching massive datasets for agencies like the CIA and NSA. Its Gotham platform became synonymous with predictive analytics in counterterrorism, while Foundry extended those capabilities to commercial clients like Airbus and BP. Fast-forward to the AI boom, and Palantir’s AIP (Artificial Intelligence Platform) has positioned it as a key player in enterprise AI, helping companies integrate data silos and deploy machine learning at scale. Revenue exploded 63% year-over-year to $1.18 billion in Q3 2025, with U.S. commercial sales surging 121% and a record backlog of deals. Management raised full-year guidance to 53% growth and projected $1.9 billion to $2.1 billion in adjusted free cash flow. It’s not just growing; it’s printing money while doing so.

So, why the sell-off? It started right after that earnings glow-up. On November 4, shares plunged 8.1% in a single day – the biggest drop since August – as investors cashed in profits from the year’s 150% rally. By mid-November, the palantir stock price had shed 14.5% in one week alone, extending into a broader tech correction where AI darlings like Nvidia and even Microsoft felt the heat. Hedge funds piled on, with two billionaire-led outfits slashing their stakes in Q3 and rotating into stabler bets like Circle Internet Financial. Then came the insider drama: CEO Alex Karp unloaded a hefty chunk of shares, sparking whispers of a lack of confidence at the top. Analysts chimed in too – TipRanks’ AI-powered model downgraded PLTR from Buy to Hold, slashing its target from $232 to $188, barely 17% above current levels. Broader fears of an AI bubble bursting, echoed by “Big Short” investor Michael Burry’s puts on Palantir and Nvidia, added fuel to the fire.

The result? A palantir stock price that’s volatile as ever, trading in a $147-$158 range last week with volume spiking to 71 million shares on down days – a sign of capitulation, sure, but also of unresolved jitters. Technicals look grim: A sell signal from the three-month MACD, support tested at $153, and resistance looming at $166. Yet, even with this 25% haircut from highs, Palantir’s allure persists. Bulls argue the dip is overdone, pointing to partnerships like the multi-million-pound deal with PwC UK for NHS data platforms and a new AI tie-up with FTAI Aviation for predictive maintenance. Five-star analyst Dan Ives is still chanting “Buy AI winners,” and Palantir’s role in the Trump administration’s rumored AI executive orders could juice defense spending. It’s tempting. But here’s where I pump the brakes: Fundamentals are one thing; pricing is another. And Palantir’s pricing is straight-up delusional.

Let’s talk valuation – the elephant in the room that’s trampling any rational case for buying now. Even after the sell-off, the palantir stock price embeds expectations of god-like growth that border on fantasy. At $160, Palantir sports a forward price-to-earnings ratio north of 240x and a price-to-sales multiple of 102x – the highest in the S&P 500 by a country mile. For context, that’s pricier than Nvidia at its peak froth and miles ahead of peers like Snowflake (P/S ~10x) or even high-flyers like CrowdStrike (~20x). Analysts’ average price target of $192 implies just 20% upside, with 14 out of 21 rating it a Hold and three screaming Strong Sell. To justify this, Palantir would need to sustain 50%+ annual revenue growth for years while margins expand to absurd levels – think 40%+ operating margins on a $4.2 billion revenue base for 2025.

But growth is already showing cracks. Q4 guidance calls for 61% year-over-year revenue jumps, but that’s sequential deceleration from Q3’s 63% – the first hint of a peak. Consensus sees full-year 2025 at 50.5%, cooling to the mid-40s in 2026. Impressive? Absolutely. Enough to warrant a market cap of $380 billion (implying 100+ years to recoup via current earnings)? Hardly. If growth halves to 25% – a realistic scenario as the low-hanging AI fruit gets picked – the stock could crater another 50% just to align with fair value multiples around 20x sales. And that’s before factoring in execution risks. Palantir’s “priced for perfection” status means any hiccup – a delayed contract, regulatory scrutiny on government ties, or even a mild recession crimping enterprise spend – sends shares spiraling. We’ve seen it before: August’s six-day skid erased 20% amid similar valuation gripes. This isn’t investing; it’s speculating on hype.

Compounding the valuation headache is Palantir’s heavy reliance on a narrow revenue moat. Government contracts still account for about 55% of sales, down from 80% a few years back but far from diversified enough for comfort. The U.S. Department of Defense is its biggest customer, and while AI demand in defense is booming (think autonomous drones and cyber ops), it’s vulnerable to budget whims and geopolitical shifts. A Democratic sweep in 2028 could slash funding for “surveillance tech,” as critics already label Palantir’s tools. Remember the backlash from 13 former employees in May, accusing the company of ditching ethical principles for Trump-aligned power grabs? That memo highlighted privacy risks and opaque data practices – issues that could invite lawsuits or boycotts from commercial clients wary of reputational taint.

On the commercial side, Palantir’s edge is real but eroding. AIP is slick for integrating disparate data sources into actionable AI insights, but competitors are closing in fast. Microsoft’s Copilot and Azure AI offer similar capabilities with deeper ecosystem ties, while open-source alternatives like Databricks undercut on price. Salesforce’s Einstein and even upstarts like C3.ai are nipping at heels with tailored vertical solutions. Palantir’s deal cycles have shortened to 3-6 months – a win – but customer concentration remains high: Just a handful of mega-deals drive backlog growth, per earnings calls. If one big fish like Merck or Sompo Holdings pulls back (as we’ve seen in tech churn), it ripples hard. And let’s not gloss over the “black box” vibe: Palantir’s secrecy, once a strength for spooks, now breeds skepticism among enterprise buyers demanding transparency in AI ethics.

Insider actions speak louder than press releases, and Palantir’s board is voting with their feet. Beyond Karp’s recent sale – timed suspiciously post-earnings – executives have offloaded over $500 million in shares this year alone, per SEC filings. Sure, it’s part of pre-planned 10b5-1 trades, but the optics? Dismal for a stock that’s up 600% from 2024 lows. When the captain jumps ship mid-voyage, even if it’s for a scheduled lifeboat drill, passengers get nervous. Wall Street agrees: Only four analysts rate it Strong Buy, versus two Strong Sells and a chorus of Holds. Top investors like those at ARK Invest have trimmed exposure, citing “bubble risks” in AI narratives. Even Karp’s own quip blaming “market manipulation” for the drop feels like deflection – ignoring how his company’s frothy multiples invited the profit-taking.

Don’t get me wrong: Palantir is a powerhouse, and AI isn’t going anywhere. Its tech solves real problems – from optimizing supply chains to spotting fraud in real-time – and 2025’s results prove the flywheel is spinning. But at today’s palantir stock price, you’re not buying a business; you’re buying a lottery ticket stamped with exponential growth assumptions. The risk-reward skews heavily toward downside: A 66% further drop would still leave it at the S&P’s priciest P/S ratio. I’d rather wait for a true capitulation, say sub-$100, where multiples compress to 20x sales and growth deceleration is baked in.

If you’re itching for AI exposure without the heartburn, look elsewhere. Microsoft (MSFT) trades at a sane 12x sales with diversified revenue (Azure AI is killing it) and a 0.7% dividend yield – up 20% YTD but with room to run on enterprise adoption. Or consider Shopify (SHOP), blending e-commerce AI tools at 10x sales, poised to eclipse Palantir’s market cap by 2028 per some forecasts. Even value plays like Philip Morris (PM) offer steady growth at half Palantir’s multiple, potentially worth more by 2026. These aren’t as sexy, but they won’t evaporate in a sentiment shift.

In the end, Palantir’s sell-off is a reality check for the AI gold rush, exposing how far speculation outpaced substance. The palantir stock price may stabilize or even rebound on fresh catalysts like UK defense expansions or holiday-season AI buzz. But until valuation comes down to Earth – and insiders stop cashing out like it’s Black Friday – it’s a pass for me. Investing isn’t about chasing yesterday’s winners; it’s about not overpaying for tomorrow’s maybes. Palantir might dominate AI in a decade, but at $160? That’s a bet I’d rather watch from the sidelines.

Exit mobile version